When Apologies Die

On my birthday, my husband, Adrian Grant, suddenly showed up with my adoptive younger sister, Bella Reed, and her child, Tia Reed.

When it was time to head out, he naturally arranged for Bella to sit in the front passenger seat. Then he turned to me and said calmly, "Tia gets carsick easily. The back seat is full of stuff. Since you're healthy, just take the bus."

Our friends immediately chimed in, one after another, "You're the older sister. Taking care of your niece is only right."

Four cars were heading out, yet not one seat was left for me, the supposed main character of the day.

I sat on the bus, swallowing my grievance, and saw Adrian and Bella interacting ambiguously in the group chat. They were even talking about topics I knew nothing about.

When I opened the newly sent video, nothing except leftovers remained on the table prepared for me.

Adrian even treated the birthday cake I had carefully prepared as dessert, spoon-feeding it to Bella and her daughter.

Someone finally couldn’t stand it anymore and asked whether this was appropriate.

Adrian, who was carefully wiping Bella’s mouth, didn’t even look up. "We’re all family. Julia won’t be angry."

At that point, our seven-year marriage came to its end.

Julia's POV

The moment Adrian Grant attentively settled Bella Reed and her daughter, Tia Reed, into the front passenger seat, I knew I was no longer the main character of this gathering.

Bella rolled down the window and gave me a sweet smile. "Julia, Adrian said today is your birthday. He specially invited us to come."

Then she added apologetically, "Sorry, Tia gets carsick easily. You don’t mind us sitting in front, right?"

I caught the faint provocation hidden in her eyes and said nothing.

Adrian placed a hand on her shoulder and spoke gently, as if soothing her. "Bella, don’t overthink it. We’re all family. How could Julia mind?"

After saying that, he opened the car door and got out, clearly intending to clear the items piled in the back seat to make space for me.

My eyes burned red. Disappointment and sadness pressed heavily against my chest.

He knew perfectly well that I didn’t like Bella, yet he still used the excuse of celebrating my birthday to bring her along.

Bella watched Adrian moving things around in the back and cast a pleading look toward the friends gathered nearby.

They understood immediately and spoke up without hesitation.

"Those are all Tia’s snacks and toys. If you take them out, the kid will be upset!"

Before the words even finished, Tia cooperated by bursting into loud tears.

Bella softly scolded her daughter, lowered her head slightly, and spoke in a tone filled with helplessness, "I’m sorry, Julia. This is all our fault for causing trouble between you and Adrian. Then we just won’t go."

She reluctantly got out of the car with the child. The little girl clung pitifully to her mother’s shoulder.

"Mom, are we really