Choosing New Love Over Old

The whispers started before I even saw them.

I was at Bridget's birthday gala, sipping champagne and laughing at her latest gossip about the Treasury Secretary's son when the room suddenly hushed. The crystal flute froze halfway to my lips as I felt dozens of eyes shift toward the entrance.

"Aria," Bridget whispered, her face draining of color. "Don't look now, but—"

But I already had.

Elliot stood in the doorway, his golden hair catching the chandelier light as it always did. But he wasn't alone. A woman with cascading dark curls and a flowing dress that couldn't quite hide her swollen belly stood beside him, her hand possessively wrapped around his arm.

"Is that—?" Someone's voice cut through the silence.

"Reyna," Elliot announced, his voice carrying across the suddenly silent ballroom. "My spiritual guide from Louisiana."

The champagne turned bitter in my mouth. Eighteen years. Eighteen years of promises, of plans, of growing up together with the understanding that one day we'd stand where we were now and announce our engagement instead.

"My spiritual guide?" I repeated, the words feeling foreign on my tongue as I finally set down my glass and moved toward them.

Reyna's eyes met mine, dark and knowing. Her lips curved into a smile that didn't reach her eyes. "The spirits guided Elliot to me," she said, her accent thick and syrupy. "He needed my wisdom."

I barely heard her. My focus was on Elliot, searching for any sign of the boy who'd promised me forever under the cherry blossoms last spring. But the man before me was a stranger, his eyes distant and cold as they swept over me.

"I've petitioned President Morrison," Elliot continued, addressing the room rather than me. "Reyna carries my child. She'll be my second wife."

The room spun around me. Second wife? Polygamy had been outlawed for generations. Even the most progressive states only recognized monogamous unions.

"You can't be serious," I managed, my voice steadier than I felt.

---

Three days later, I stood in the Simmons family drawing room, my hands clasped so tightly my nails left crescent moons in my palms. The familiar mahogany furniture and hunting prints that had witnessed our childhood promises now seemed to mock me.

"Eighteen years, Elliot," I said, fighting to keep my voice from breaking. "Eighteen years, and you throw it away for... what? Some mystical awakening?"

Elliot paced before the fireplace, his profile sharp against the dancing flames. "You don't understand, Aria. What Reyna and I share transcends ordinary love."

"Transcends?" I laughed, the sound brittle even to my own ears. "Is that what we call it when you bring home your pregnant mistress?"

Reyna stood by the window, one hand resting on her rounded belly. The late afternoon sun caught the silver pendant at her throat—a crescent moon with a star, symbols I didn't recognize.

"The child is Elliot's spiritual heir," she said softly. "The spirits chose me to guide him to his true path."

I ignored her,